Why New CEOs Fail in Their First Year

Steve Weiss, ACC
November 13, 2026

Last updated: November 15, 2026

Share this:
Stressed CEO holds his head in a tense boardroom meeting with concerned executives around the table

New leaders are struggling more than ever to get past their first year in the corner office. And most of them aren't failing for lack of skill. There were 168 new chief executives named to the S&P 1500 last year, the most since 2010. Of the new CEO appointments globally in 2025, 86% went to people who had never run a public company before. Eleven CEOs left in their first year, tying the record. Exits between 30 and 36 months into the job were up 79% from the year before.

It doesn't matter if you're a first-time CEO or a first-time shift lead. The reasons for the quick exits are the same. It's not because of the skills that got them promoted. It's because of how they handle people and pressure.

"We Didn't Test at Apple"

J.C. Penney hired Ron Johnson as their chief executive in 2011. Johnson had pioneered the idea of the Apple retail stores and the Genius Bar. Investors thought he'd bring the same magic to Penney. It was his first time as a CEO.

Johnson moved quickly. He got rid of coupons, clearance racks, and sales events. He wanted to replace those with designer boutiques inside the stores. When someone suggested testing the new pricing first, Johnson reportedly said, "We didn't test at Apple."

Penney's shoppers weren't Apple shoppers. Sales cratered through early 2012. When customers weren't coming in, Johnson said they needed to be educated on the new pricing. Long time employees inside the company felt like the new hires were judging them. There was a constant drumbeat of Apple references. One regional executive said no one felt like they could tell Johnson or corporate that his timelines were impossible.

Johnson was removed by the board after 17 months. His predecessor was brought back. The board felt like he was disconnected from the company's customers, the workforce, and the company culture.

It wasn't that Johnson didn't have talent. He failed because he took what had worked in the past and didn't learn about where he was. And the people around him stopped telling him the truth.

Skill Gets You Hired. Something Else Gets You Fired.

Johnson's case is far more common than it looks. Leadership IQ did a study of more than 20,000 hires. 46% of them failed within 18 months. And it wasn't because of technical skills. 26% of those who failed couldn't take feedback. 23% couldn't understand and manage their emotions. This study included new hires at all levels, not just executives.

It's the same story at the top. A survey of 320 executives and talent professionals found that more than 20% of internal promotions and 30% of external executive hires were considered failures within 2 years. More than 75% cited poor interpersonal skills as the primary reason for failure. Poor relationship building, influence, and communication.

Four Traps of the First Year

The leadership consulting firm Navalent did a 10-year study of executive performance. They did 2,600 in-depth interviews with Fortune 1000 executives. They found four traps that can catch talented people.

The Mandate Trap

New leaders come in feeling like they're there to repeat past success. So they take the old formulas and apply them to the new situation without first studying the situation. This is Johnson's story in one sentence.

Stakeholder Blindness

New leaders don't realize how much they need trusted partnerships with the people whose support will make or break them.

Altitude Distortion

One of the study authors, Ron Carucci, says new executives should "assume you now have a megaphone strapped to you 24/7." Everything you say is amplified. And what information you receive is filtered. Because people will tell you what they think you want to hear.

Power Failure

This isn't what most people think. It's more commonly the avoidance of power than the abuse of power. It's indecision. Tolerating mediocrity. Hiding behind others when the risks are high.

Same Traps At All Levels

These traps all apply when a line cook becomes a sous chef. When a nurse becomes a charge nurse. When an engineer becomes a manager. The megaphone gets louder as you go up. But the traps remain the same.

The current wave of turnover makes this more pressing. When a new CEO arrives, the rest of the C-suite often turns over too, as the new chief executive builds a team to carry out their vision. At S&P 500 companies, more than one in five leadership roles was filled by someone new in 2025, up from about one in seven in 2023. That is more than 1,400 new senior leaders in a single year. Each of them then reshapes their own teams. One new CEO can set off a chain of new leaders several levels down. And all of them are in their first year at the same time.

What Protects a New Leader

Most new leaders don't have much support in that first year. In the Navalent study, 55% of new executives said they had minimal or no ongoing coaching and feedback to help them grow into the role. In the survey of 320 executives and talent professionals, they cited mentoring, a customized plan for a strong start, and a coach who understands the organization as the three things that helped most.

As a coach, I believe emotional intelligence and resilience are the foundation of all other leadership skills. And they can be built. They are tested harder in that first year than any other time in a leader's career. It's emotional intelligence that helps you notice that the room has gone quiet when you expected agreement. It's resilience that helps you hear "this isn't working" without defending yourself. And then change course.

In practice, this means a few simple habits:

  • You spend your first months learning before you start changing.
  • You find at least one person who will tell you the truth, and make it safe for them to continue doing so.
  • You realize your words carry more weight now than you intend.
  • When it's your call on a hard one, you make it.

One Practice for This Week

If you're new in a role or about to be, before you start changing anything, ask three people this question:

What do you wish the last leader had understood about this place?

Then listen. And write down what you hear.

If you've been in your role for years, ask the newest person on your team what surprised them when they arrived. They can still see what you've stopped noticing.

Ron Johnson didn't test his ideas at J.C. Penney. The leaders who last are the ones who test their assumptions. Starting with what they think they already know.

Sources

CEO turnover and first-time CEOs: Spencer Stuart, S&P 1500 CEO Transitions Report, via Hunt Scanlon
https://huntscanlon.com/ceo-turnover-surges-as-boards-bet-on-first-time-leaders/

Russell Reynolds Associates, Global CEO Turnover Index, via the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance
https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/?p=181137

Russell Reynolds Associates data on first-year and short-tenure exits, via The Corporate Governance Institute
https://membership.thecorporategovernanceinstitute.com/news/13047031

Ron Johnson at J.C. Penney: Chief Executive
https://chiefexecutive.net/5-critical-errors-that-triggered-ron-johnsons-removal-at-jc-penney/

HuffPost
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/jcpenney-pricing-disaster-morale_n_3196037/amp

Associated Press, via Salon
https://www.salon.com/2013/04/09/jc_penney_turns_to_former_ceo_ap/

Engadget
https://www.engadget.com/2013/04/14/how-ron-johnson-tried-and-failed-to-inject-a-bit-of-apple-cult/

Leadership IQ study of new hires: Onrec
https://www.onrec.com/node/87902

Alexcel Group and Institute of Executive Development survey: Government Executive
https://www.govexec.com/management/2011/03/the-big-reasons-new-executives-fail-and-what-to-do-about-them/40438/

Navalent study and Ron Carucci: World Economic Forum
https://www.weforum.org/stories/2015/03/4-common-reasons-half-of-all-new-executives-fail/

Cascading C-suite turnover: Altrata, "Hiring Accelerates on Leadership Teams"
https://altrata.com/articles/executive-turnover-trends-on-leadership-teams

💡 Ready to apply these insights?

Schedule a free 30-minute discovery call to discuss how executive coaching can help you achieve your leadership goals.

About the Author

Steve Weiss: ICF ACC Credentialed, Level 2 Certified Executive Coach

Steve Weiss

ICF ACC Credentialed, Level 2 Certified Executive Coach

ICF ACC Credentialed, Level 2 Certified Executive Coach and Leadership Consultant

Steve Weiss is an ICF ACC Credentialed, Level 2 Certified Executive Coach and Certified Hogan Assessments Consultant with 30+ years of executive leadership experience. Steve Weiss of Catalis Leadership has completed the Accreditation Program for Leadership/Impact® (opens in a new tab) and Management/Impact® (opens in a new tab) by Human Synergistics. Based in Cleveland, Ohio, he works with leaders locally, nationally, and globally to transform their leadership impact.

ICF ACC Credentialed, Level 2 Certified Executive Coach
Hogan Certified Consultant

Leadership/Impact® and Management/Impact® are registered trademarks of Human Synergistics International.

Found this helpful?

Let's explore your vision for your team and the leader you want to be.